top of page

The Battle Over Appraisal Rights: How Insurance Companies are Sidestepping Policyholder Privileges

Insurance policies are essentially a contract between the policyholder and the insurance company. They promise coverage and compensation for specific events or damages. Central to this promise is the principle of fairness, ensuring both parties are treated justly in case of a dispute. One such mechanism for dispute resolution is the 'appraisal' process. However, there's a growing trend among insurance companies to deny policyholders their rightful opportunity to invoke appraisal. Let's delve into this concerning trend.

At its core, the appraisal process is a method to resolve disagreements over the cost of damages. When a policyholder and insurance company can't agree on the amount of loss, either party can demand an appraisal. Each side selects an appraiser, and together, they choose an umpire. If the two appraisers can't agree on a loss amount, they present their differences to the umpire, whose decision is binding. This system was designed to be unbiased and expedient.

With an increasing frequency, insurance companies are sidestepping this appraisal process. The reasons often boil down to a few key motivations:

1. Control Over Claims: By keeping the appraisal process at bay, insurance companies retain more control over the claim's outcome, which might lead to settlements more favorable to them.

2. Delaying Tactics: Appraisal can expedite claim settlements. By denying this right, insurance companies can prolong the claim process, often leading policyholders to accept lower settlements out of desperation.

3. Minimizing Payouts: In the absence of an independent appraisal, insurance companies have a better cha

nce of keeping their payout amounts on the lower end of the spectrum.

The Legal Ambiguities:

A significant issue arises from the way appraisal clauses are written in insurance policies. These clauses can often be ambiguous, giving insurance companies a loophole to deny appraisal rights. By arguing over the interpretation of what constitutes a "disagreement over the amount of loss," they can sometimes skirt around invoking the appraisal process.

The Impact on Policyholders:

This denial of appraisal rights has profound consequences for policyholders:

1. Financial Strain: Without the appraisal process, policyholders may receive compensation far less than what's required to cover their damages or losses, leading to financial hardships.

2. Extended Recovery Times: The delay in settling claims means that policyholders might take longer to recover or rebuild after a loss.

3. Loss of Trust: Trust is the bedrock of any insurance contract. Denying rightful processes like appraisal erodes this trust, making policyholders wary and uncertain about their coverage.

What Can Policyholders Do?

If you're a policyholder facing a denial of your right to invoke appraisal, consider the following steps:

1. Revisit Your Policy: Always start by thoroughly reading your insurance policy. Understand your rights and the specific language around the appraisal clause.

2. Document Everything: Ensure you have a well-documented record of all communications with your insurance company. This can be crucial if you decide to take legal action.

3. Seek Legal Counsel: If you believe your rights are being denied, it might be time to consult with an attorney who specializes in insurance claims. They can guide you on the best course of action and represent your interests.

4. Raise Awareness: Sharing your experience can warn others. Whether it's through social media, community gatherings, or local media, making others aware can put collective pressure on insurance companies to act ethically.

The denial of the right to invoke appraisal by insurance companies is a pressing concern. It not only undermines the principle of fairness but also leaves policyholders in challenging situations. While insurance companies have a duty to safeguard their interests, this shouldn't come at the expense of denying legitimate rights to policyholders. As consumers, staying informed, vigilant, and proactive is essential to ensuring that the scales of justice remain balanced.


bottom of page